Showing posts with label dealing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dealing. Show all posts

The problem of solving problems

If you want to read upbeat, perky posts about the business of life and a life in business, you might want to subscribe to Claire Diaz Ortiz.  One of her recent posts was about problem solving and it  was definitely something I could relate to.

Claire suggests that you should ask yourself three questions before jumping into solving problems (I'm paraphrasing a bit): Is it really a problem? Do I want to do something about it? Should I do something now or later?

All valid questions, though most of us just jump into solving problems, or, more accurately, reacting to problems, without much thought, unless they tend to be big enough to warrant analysis before resolution.  But, if we do take the time to step back and consider problems, there is one important question that I would add to this list: Who owns the problem?

Answering the question of who owns the problem often changes the definition of, and the resultant solution to, the problem.  For example, you might say 'My coworker keeps eating chips half the day and the sound drives me nuts'.   Who owns the problem?  You might be tempted to say it's the coworker, but he's obviously having fun chomping down on the chips without a care as to what you think about it or what it's doing to his waistline.  It is you who owns the problem, and now the problem is not that he snacks on chips loudly but that you are bothered by it and might be better off investing in noise-canceling headphones.

Of course, if the problem is not owned by you, it can't be solved by you either - something that every parent should remember before taking over their kid's science projects.  Though I must admit there are some of us who actually enjoy solving other people's problems, way more engaging than grappling with Sudoku.  Ah well, we can't all be Dear Abby.

(Image courtesy of photoexplorer / FreeDigitalPhotos.net)

Frownies and smilies

Customer feedback is what makes the whole venture real for an entrepreneur.  Sure, validation is the number of users, the number of units sold, the amount of revenue received - but the quantitative stuff is never enough.  You want to know what the users think, how much they like what you're doing and why.

So you actively seek customer feedback, especially in the early stages as that is going to inform your product and marketing strategies.  And when you get the 'wow!', 'cool', you're thrilled.

Then you run across the first customer who is not a fan of whatever you're doing and let's you know that in definitive terms with feedback itemizing the many different ways your product fails to impress.  Your initial reaction is most likely a sinking feeling, tinged with a little 'what if nobody likes it?'.  The next one is that the customer doesn't really get it and you're not going to pay any attention to the feed.  Luckily your business sense kicks in and you start looking at what the feedback is about.  You put yourself in the shoes of the customer and try to see what could have happened and what you can do about it.  And if you're super customer-centric (as you should be) you reach out to the customer with a reasoned response and maybe notch a win.  Negative feedback can bring positive results.

Handling feedback in business is pretty much like how you would do it in other areas of your life.  Enjoy the kudos, but don't disregard the criticism and don't let it crush you by taking it personally.  Take a few steps back (and a few deep breaths!) and try to find value in the feedback.  Your product - and you - will be the better for it. 
As they say, a frown is just an upside down smile.  


 

The work of life

For sure cave people never despaired of finding work/life balance. Back then, just living was work - escaping the pesky predators, chasing dinner on the hoof, having a kid or ten before succumbing to some random illness just because you scratched yourself inappropriately. But civilization happened and over time there rose the concept that work was what you did so you could have a life, sometimes in the literal sense. And then there developed a choice, for a few, where working became 'living', a neat flip from the primeval position.

Entrepreneurs routinely face the question of whether they're spending too much time on work. The irony is that everyone (who can afford the choice) is exhorted to find a way to make a living 'doing what you love', and if you love doing something, the chances are you're going to do it a lot. Most entrepreneurs don't feel they're working - at least not toiling - they're just doing what feels right. But, there's the 'life' part with significant others, spouses, children, parents, siblings - the people who you may feel responsible for in some way. There are many VCs and startup pundits who actively subscribe to the conventional wisdom that the best entrepreneur is someone young and 'unencumbered' - someone who can put 150% into the venture. All young people are not able - or often, not willing - to put in that kind of commitment though. Entrepreneurship is not determined by age but the compelling desire to start a company - and if you have that, lack of encumbrances of course make it easier for the entrepreneur to put undivided attention to the company. But (yes, there's a 'but' here), do you want an entrepreneur whose world view is just the company and nothing else? It is interesting to see how so many CEOs feel they have to show how they have 'full', 'normal' lives with the requisite social, and socially-conscious, commitments, the sports (sometimes extreme) as well as photo-perfect families (unless you're young Mark Zuckerberg of course).

So assuming that the entrepreneur has something outside of the startup that s/he wants to hold on to, there is always the problem of finding balance and the solution is individualized. Here's an older post (lies entrepreneurs tell themselves) which I'd read a little while ago that lays out one entrepreneur's take. While this addresses the day-to-day ongoing balance between work and family, the being-home-for-dinner-two-days-a-week sort of thing, the bigger challenge is when something 'big' comes along and demands a ton of your time as well as emotional and mental focus. This is not as unlikely as we would like it to be, accidents happen, people in your life can get critically ill and it may take something more than a trip to the zoo or a weekend getaway from you. This is when the entrepreneur's mettle is really tested. You can't give up your family responsibilities as there are people depending on you and you can't give up on your company as other people are depending on you too, though in a different way. The only thing you can do is cope. Focus on what's critical for the near term, both at work and home, and let the other stuff slide. And get help - if you had a team that you can delegate to, it would relieve some of the stress while still helping you get things done. It may be difficult to have that kind of support if your startup is in a really early stage, but then again, if it is not quite established you may have more flexibility - and maybe you should start looking for management support sooner then later. It also helps if you have plans in place so your team can continue getting things done even without your constant hour-to-hour involvement. Team + plans in place - not just good for routine productivity but also for crisis times when you can't be there 100%. And while you're juggling all these challenges, remember to take time out for yourself - so you are able to pick up where you left off when the times once again pass from crisis to routine and work/life balance is back to remembering to show up for dinner.

Decide to act

I remember the bane of 'analysis paralysis' from my corporate years - there was always one faction that favored lengthy and laborious analysis before even agreeing to a proposal, sometimes to the extent that the proposal became obsolete. While understanding and supporting the need for analysis, I personally preferred the 'do your homework quickly, highlight the risks, plan an escape route and then go for it' approach myself and often had to dig in deep to find patience when faced with endless analysis that I couldn't control.

But for an entrepreneur, quick decisions are a necessity not an option. In an earlier post I'd written about the adaptive startup and why it is important for a startup to change, but there has to be a decision to act first in order to have something that requires change. As an early stage entrepreneur, you have to remember there's no such thing as a perfect product or a perfect market or even a perfect team - you've got to lead with what you've got and make something happen. Granted you may find that you've headed in the wrong direction and you have to make course corrections, but at least you're moving. It's hard to be agile if you're static.

I was reminded of this recently by two things. First, I was contemplating launching a new program but was concerned about the fact that the software was missing a couple of features that I felt to be key and that I didn't have dedicated resources to get started. Most of all I wasn't sure this program would even be successful though on paper it seemed so, and it didn't help that everyone around me was in tactical mode and couldn't meaningfully engage in a discussion in a timely manner. The standard process would have been to take more time to do deeper analysis on viability as well as assess the software changes impact before making the decision to go ahead. All it took was one simple 'aha' moment to remember that the program could be launched as a contained pilot and the software features could be (I was sure they would be) suggestions from the users and prioritized by them. I made the decision to get started and I'm happy to say the program's well on its way and everything is falling into place as part of just getting it done - that includes the resources.

Soon after I'd made the decision, I ran across this post which delivered a virtual pat on the back validating the entrepreneur's need for quick decisions - and by implication, quick action. It is well known that the idea alone is not sufficient for a successful startup, it's the execution of the idea that counts - and execution is all about deciding and doing. As an entrepreneur remember you have a need, a need for speed!

Words Shape the Venture

No, it's not the other way about, even though it seem counter-intuitive. Ideally, you should write down your business plan early enough in the game just so you can makes sure that you've answered all the obvious questions and you know there's a business there. You think of your idea, you start to build it (whether it's a product or service) and somewhere along the way, you have to write down what your idea is all about, either to get funding or to market to customers. But apart from the plan, there's the description, often the elevator pitch or one-liner or even the tag line, that you start working on the moment you're ready to talk to other people about your idea and you'll soon find out that these words are more than just 'marketing', they're critical to your business.

First, the very act of trying to describe what your business is about turns out to be a most challenging exercise. It could take you weeks of creating, analyzing and re-creating to come up with something that you believe represents what you are doing. And doing it in clear language takes a little bit more (help from more 'literary' types). Finally it's done and you're excited as you can now build 'a widget that keeps people from losing their marbles'. (Maybe the figurative kind? That would be something.)

So what you have is a nifty way to track marbles, and you think you have a great way to distribute to a large market and make money so you're marching along. And one day, you are putting together a brief summary to send to a business acquaintance who knows someone who is involved in a fund where a partner is super interested in marbles (this is how it often goes). You read your description again and decide that all this time you've been working on the tracking but haven't paid attention to how people would use it. So now you decide you need to focus on the user experience of using the tracking to find the said marbles. Still, it's early enough in the game and it's all good.

And you keep going, and you're reviewing your presentation that you'd be making to a VC soon and the word 'people' hits you. Do you really want to say 'people' which may mean individuals, consumers, or are you really focusing on selling to organizations which may then help people with their marbles? This warrants a sit-down with your team and discussions on which would be the better market, and you decide to focus on individual consumers, especially since your sales and marketing guy assures you that there's not much profit in selling to middle-men. By this time you feel that your team knows exactly what to do and you've laid it all out, and you can confidently answer when the VC asks you 'which people?' or anything else about your product.

You are getting deeper into your business and now you find that there are others out there who are also positioning themselves as having marble trackers like yours and, crushingly, it's not just a startup or two, but a big gun (or two) with the means to take you out before you get established. Since you're a true entrepreneur, you don't just throw up your hands in despair, but you go back to the fundamentals and look at what you set out to do: provide a widget that keeps people from losing their marbles. And the bells clang in your head - your differentiator is in 'keep from losing' - you're not just going to track marbles and help find them once lost, you are going to keep people from losing them in the first place. Maybe that would take not only a widget, but a service, but your team thinks that's great because the big guns aren't going to bother with that and would leave the field to you and the other smaller fry. And as an added bonus, you now have a new exit strategy as maybe one of those abundantly sized guns could buy you out in the future.

Articulating your business and vision in clear terms is critical, not only for selling it to others, but to keep you and your team on track by providing a solid touchstone for every strategic decision you have to make. Not to mention, it may keep you from losing your marbles!

Beyond the business plan

A few months ago, I'd written a post about the team of teens I was mentoring in presenting their business plan. A quick recap: these are under-resourced high-school students who get substantial support and guidance in making it to college, along with hands-on lessons in entrepreneurship. They're supported by the non-profit BUILD and you can read my previous posts on these teen entrepreneurs here and here. Those 9th-graders have now moved on to 10-grade and have opted to continue with their business idea (and more importantly, high-school - yeah!) and I'm back to mentoring them in their trek from plan to product and having a lot of fun in the process.

So, we're picking up where we left off before summer started - the team had pitched their idea (personalized clip-on charms - no IP to protect here), their differentiators and their business plan, and it all looked viable, so come fall, they were green-lighted to start their business as long as they kept up their academic commitments. But, the three months between summer and fall is a long time in the life of a teenager, and many things changed. Most dramatically, the team's CFO and CMO dropped out of the program and the rest of them were not confident about the product/process anymore.

Surprisingly, this did not cause them to doubt their ability to start their company. A while ago, I'd written about how startups have to be flexible to survive ('The Adaptive Startup') and it is so refreshing to see how these teens are re-shuffling their plans with alacrity. They are not stuck on their old plans and show no inertia or resistance to change. They got two more kids to join their team, reassigned roles, got inspired by one of the newcomers' football charm and are re-doing their 'manufacturing' plans. My co-mentor and I are amazed at how quickly they dropped the one-off, custom-everything approach they were leaning towards when they figured out how much time (and money) that would take and are now measuring everything on a feasibility scale. They're energetically trying to balance practicality with coolness (essential to teendom) and us mentors cheered (silently) when they dropped the idea of buying their own $1000 metal engraver in favor of outsourcing but kept their original designs. Another familiar startup lesson here - focus on your value-add and get others to do the routine/commodity stuff.

As these teens are reminding us, life, and startups, can be unpredictable, and resilience and adaptability seem to trump conformance and control in bringing success - and satisfaction.

Dealing with deafening silence

The previous post was all about asking - the entrepreneur shouldn't be afraid to ask for suggestions, resources, contacts, office space and the ever-important funding. You can expect different responses of course, and maybe I'll cover them another time, but this post is all about a specific response: silence.

It was only after I started a company that I found out that many people seem to believe silence is an acceptable response in the business world. It's perfectly understandable as a go-to solution for invitations from people you want to avoid, especially when you're thirteen years old and haven't got the art of the white-lie down yet ("I'm washing my hair and it's a personal religious ritual"). And I am eternally grateful I can 'ignore' any number of requests and invitations on Facebook - I mean, actively getting a sense of closure by clicking 'ignore' instead of just sighing and looking away. No, this is not about silence as a avoidance technique in awkward social situations, where it definitely has a respected place.

In the startup world, silence as an answer seems ever so common. So you are introduced to a potential investor who wants your exec summary, your PowerPoint stack and maybe even a meeting. And possibly follow up emails asking probing questions on marketing plans and competitive pressures. All good. You're excited that there's so much interest and have kept pace, changing your pitch to answer the questions and doing rapid research to back up your claims. You think that even if there's no investment you'll find out what you need to improve, after all, you've been in almost twice daily contact if you count the emails. And then - nothing. A week passes. You give the investor the benefit of the doubt - he's busy, she's traveling, they have an offsite retreat. So you send an upbeat email, carefully worded not to sound desperate, and yet inviting a hit on the reply button. Still nothing. You wait another week and send another 'anything else I can do?' message. Nada. Depending on your fortitude, you could keep up the 'ping! remember me? what do you think?' one-sided messaging going on for quite a while.

This doesn't happen just when asking for money. You are introduced to a great customer referral and after the initial enthusiasm of demos and deep-dives, it all fizzles out. Or the candidate who thinks yours is the best company in the world who disappears in the middle of the interview cycle. It could even be the independent contractor who's dependably provided you with services (and been dependably paid by you) for a long time who seems to have gone off the grid and doesn't reply to your latest project request.

That's it. You don't get a 'No, not interested'. Or even a qualified 'Not right now'. Just silence. So what do you think/feel/do? First, don't take it personally. Or then again, do - in a good way. Use this to improve your own follow up and closing the loop track record. If you look back at your own actions, there must be someone you just plain forgot to respond to, even though you intended to follow up. It happens to everyone. Which is why it is perfectly OK to send a reminder or two - understanding, not accusatory, ones. And if that doesn't work, you should realize it's not about forgetting, but mostly about not knowing how to say 'no' gracefully and professionally without closing any doors. You could indulge in rants from "B-schools don't teach business etiquette" to creative name-calling, but that's not going to get you anything except heartburn. If you check out TheFunded.com you'll find many entrepreneurs who give props to VCs who reject their pitch quickly and cleanly, and it is likely this kind of feedback would have an impact - in the investor circles at least. So, if the reminders still elicit silence, it's time to stop reaching out. It's not about angrily deleting the 'silent ones' from your contact list - but instead adding them to the distribution list for your newsletter, or blog or other cheery updates about your business. Maybe they will click on one of these some day, see how you're doing, and get back in touch with you. After all, they never said 'No' and you know better than to close any doors.

Opportunities from obstacles

Continuing the musings on dealing with economic turmoil, there's a another worldview - this is just business as usual in emerging markets like Asia, Eastern Europe, Latin America etc. Having just returned from a quick trip to India where everyone I met talked to me about the US downturn , I agree there's something to be learned from countries where economic stability is not taken for granted.

The Wall Street Journal recently had an article on Surviving the Downturn: Lessons from Emerging Markets which is interesting reading. The primary lesson here is that while we in the US, and presumably other developed countries, have a tendency to shrink, retrench, hunker down and other 'fall back' actions, there's a case to be made for seeking growth, as they do in other places. While the article is focused on larger companies, the ideas apply to small startups just as well. For example, the one about increasing product and service visibility - that can be done with a team of one (yourself, the entrepreneur) if need be, and is a great investment as I'd mentioned in a previous post 'time to build'.

The other idea on rethinking customer value is a call for flexibility - and really paying attention to what your customer wants, especially during this time. It helps to understand that value may not always be just about cutting prices. I shop frequently at a Trader Joe's close to my home and used to worry about the survival of a little independent produce store right next to it - it had too little produce and too few customers and I thought it would go under, especially as the economy tightened. But, the management decided to pump it up, put up huge banners stressing 'neighborhood', 'independent', ' farm fresh', all guaranteed to appeal to the kind of people who go to TJ's, and it is now literally overflowing with produce and bustling with customers. They did a little bit of both - increased visibility and paid attention to what the customers value - and are reaping the profits.

Finally, the article ends by emphasizing the underlying theme: stay optimistic. It is not easy, particularly with the daily dose of doom around you, but it is a choice you can make - and a forward-thinking approach will get you focusing on growth, instead of just survival, which vastly increases your chances of being around when the upswing happens. Not to mention, when you stop panicking, you'll have more fun and be more fun too. In a networked world, good ideas flow in all directions.

Time to build

It's two weeks into the new year, and many are still refining (if not defining) their resolutions, regardless of what the gym ads say. Maybe it's because those resolutions made in the hopeful haze of the holidays don't hold up as January briskly marches on.

Well, this blog is about the startup ethos, and I don't do resolutions - but I do plan. And as the year ended, I, like many others, had to review the financials, the marketing and development plans, yada yada. Planning at year end is pretty much a given for any entrepreneur. But last year was not just any old year, and 2009 is starting from the ashes of what was simultaneously the bleakest year for the global economy but also the most hopeful year in American politics, and needless to say, the two are intertwined.

There have been many writings about how startups can survive the year ahead. There was the famous Sequoia presentation that started the belt-tightening in the VC and startup communities of Silicon Valley, and a flurry of how-to-survive posts from CEOs - you can read one here or here. All very useful, but also all oriented to those that have some level of funding or an established revenue stream. What about the entrepreneur who has just started out? How do you grow when everyone's pulling back?

I believe that now's the time to build. That doesn't mean that we sit back and wait for the government to infuse funds and start projects. We need that of course, but what we do at the personal level will have a ripple effect at the global level - if enough of us do it. And for an entrepreneur, in any area, just sitting around wringing hands and bemoaning fates/financiers/politicians is not an option. It's not in our DNA. We've got to be making something happen or we...er, move on.

So how do you build your business with little on no money? Very simply, you need to invest. You need to make an investment of time, energy and mind-share, if not money. Here are some ways you can build:

1. Invest in customers.
  • Get to know your current and future customers/users. Build relationships that you can leverage when they have money to spend or you have the money to deliver. This works for every level, from large enterprises to individual consumers. Even when you're cutting back on spending, or specially then, the promise of new ideas and innovation on the horizon is always sexy.
  • Do stuff for free for your users/customers. What you give away now will help you get revenue later.
2. Invest in domain expertise.
  • Improve your expertise in your chosen area. Build skills and knowledge, do market research, do competitive analysis, talk to customers (see a pattern here?). Get better at what you do.
  • Help your team members, if you have any, do the same.
3. Invest in your product/service and infrastructure.
  • Build out your product or service. There are folks out there who're either stuck in paying, but boring, jobs or out looking for a job and willing to hone their skills 'donating' a few hours for you. If you're in the service business, take this opportunity to refine/streamline your offerings.
  • Talk to customers/users (again!) to make sure you're positioning your product/service for the new environment we're facing.
  • Improve your infrastructure and processes, stuff like file sharing, accounting or technical documentation.
4. Invest in connections.
  • Meet people and establish genuine connections, not just the biz card swap. Customers and users (of course), advisors, tech and domain experts, and even funding sources. Even if they're not investing now, they could help later. Though personally I'm not a fan of doing the 'VC pitch' when there's no hope of funding, I think it helps just to get to know the people in the know.
5. Invest in marketing.
  • No, this doesn't require much money, or even a marketing person on your team. You can spiff up your website (at least update the content), spiff up your presentations and fact sheets, set up blogs and user communities, and generally polish and spread the word.
Assuming you're already taking care of the 'making a living' part, there's still plenty you can do to build your business now so you're poised to take off when things improve, as they will. So build now and you can fly later.

The sky is falling

It sure looks like it, given the financial news worldwide. Stocks falling, credit freezing, centuries-old bastions of industry faltering. It's not pretty, and no one knows what's going to happen next. So what does it mean for entrepreneurs who're just starting out?

In the high tech world, when top venture capitalists speak, Silicon Valley, and as we (possibly hubristically) believe, the world, listens. They have been well covered in other blogs; TechCrunch has Sequoia's 'doom' outlook, Benchmark's call to frugality and angel investor Ron Conway's cautionary memo - all very interesting and must-read. Most of the focus is on companies that are already funded, not early stage ones that are hoping to get there, but the message is pretty similar for both: don't expect funding. The prevailing mood is dour and the call-to-action is 'hunker-down'. Nothing unusual though - VCs are typically conservative, though they're ostensibly in the business of taking risks - nobody gets fired for preaching thriftness (with impending doom).

But I'm not alone in thinking that entrepreneurs do have an opportunity in this climate and a startup is not a bad place to be in. While the VCs are talking mostly about funded companies, the warning on scarcity of funding is probably even more true for the fledgling startup. Even if you aren't doing a startup which requires funding, you still have to face an environment where customers are not quick to buy anything. so, if you have mortgages to pay off and mouths to feed, I wouldn't recommend quitting to start something. But if you're unencumbered and/or find yourself out of a job, or if you have some spare time for moonlighting, and have an idea that's you're burning to try out, now may be a good time to do so.

Successfully launching a startup in these times comes down to four things. The first is your idea. Is it something that can be done with little money? When do you have to go to market? If it is in the near future, it had better smell 'recession-proof' and that's no mean feat. There are many who think that means saving a few bucks for their customer, but a lower price is meaningless if it is something your customer can do without. What you offer should be obviously of value to your customer/user today, without needing a sales spin or convincing, and should be competitively priced. Then you'll have a chance of gaining traction in the market.

The second is execution. Your awesome value-delivering idea is just that, an idea, not a successful company, if you can't execute on it. And in lean times, execution is about getting stuff done with little money. Which means thinking frugally at every step and finding alternatives. You have to make tough choices and may find your timeline slipping because you don't have the resources, but that is better than slipping on quality. But 'getting stuff done' also means staying focused and not letting your vision slide along with stock prices on Wall Street.

The third item is your team. Even if you only have a couple of people moonlighting on your venture, you'll see upward momentum if they have a 'can-do' spirit and feel ownership in the success of the company. And it is always more uplifting to be with pragmatic, but positive, people than those who gripe and groan - when times are bleak, you don't want your team to be ditto.

The fourth is what kind of an entrepreneur you are. If you're focused, flexible, determined and unafraid to work with little money while diligent about seeking more, you have a much better chance of survival. If you tire quickly of lean budgets and making-do, this is not the time for your startup. The bar is higher during tough times, but not impossible to clear, and if you can do that, you'll still be standing when the sky is raised again.

Doubt, caution

First off, I admit to having my post titles influenced by catchy movie ones ;)

It's pretty much established that an entrepreneur has to be passionately committed to his/her idea, and believe in it - s/he needs to be a bouncing poster child for optimism. This kind of gung-ho dedication is a must-have to lead the troops and stick it through the ups and downs (the many downs) of a startup. All the entrepreneur self-help books will tell you so.

But, there are times, usually in the wee hours of the morning, when a person may be visited by the dreaded 'doubt'. What if I never get funding? What if my idea turns out to be a stinker? What if I don't have what it takes to get this done? Conventional wisdom says you shouldn't be thinking such things, but isn't that just sticking your head in the sand and refusing to face reality?

Conventional wisdom is spot on in this case. An entrepreneur has no use for doubt, but can benefit from a healthy dose of caution. 'What if I don't get funding?' is better replaced by 'What are my options for boot-strapping?'. 'I should develop a plan to validate and refine the concept' is a much more useful approach than dire imaginings of your idea flopping like a goldfish fallen on the floor. Figuring what's required to get the job done and who can complement your skills is vastly more productive than wallowing in despair over your perceived shortcomings, be it lack of experience or a lack of a high net worth network.

The entrepreneur has to be both an optimist and a pragmatist, but also swiftly squelch any signs of doubt. Let others audition for the role of doubting Thomas, they don't have much to lose.

A surfeit of opinions

Everyone has an opinion. On everything. But that's kind of what you're betting on when you go out gathering 'input', asking for 'feedback', 'guidance' or 'advice' from the 3 Fs (in this case, family, friends and their friends - subbing for the 'fools' that traditionally play the third F). You're hoping that taking your idea or pitch to them will give you access to their knowledge, experience, smarts and plain good sense so you can vet it for free.

And you find you get a lot of opinions. You may be asked to 'wag the long tail' or 'take a page out of Facebook'. S/he may direct you to add more detail to your pitch, change your pricing model, go for more or less money, seek out VCs or pray for angels. Of course, seeking opinions is not just for startup entrepreneurs. A student could be asking for help on essay for college apps, an exec considering a career change, a book idea, whatever. And they're all just as likely to receive opinions that cover the gamut from minor tweaks to major re-dos.

So, now you have all these opinions, what do you do with them? Which ones do you take to heart? There are a few things that you can do to help handle this over-abundance of input.
  1. Listen. Obviously whoever you share your plans and ideas with is someone who you think will have something worthwhile to say. So, once you're done showing the presentation, explaining your idea, sharing your essay or novel outline, stop talking and start listening. Ask questions to get the ball rolling if you have to (have they seen anything like this before?) but make sure you get what you want - their unfiltered opinion.
  2. Give them credit. If your advisors suggest stuff you've already thought of, it is OK to keep that to yourself and show your appreciation. Having them involved in your idea is a good thing.
  3. Do explain. If there appears to be some misunderstanding about your offering, that in itself is good feedback - it shows that you need to refine it so there's no chance of confusion. To repeat, if you choose to ask someone for advice, you obviously think they're smart enough to get it, and if they didn't, it implies that something got lost in the presentation.
  4. Do not defend. If your advisor thinks your market strategy is nothing more than a shot at lucid dreaming, ask him why. If you have some more information to share that may change his thinking, go ahead and share it. Otherwise, there is little benefit to arguing a point. Assuming he understands what your proposing correctly, maybe he has a valid point. You're better off with a 'Good point. I'll think about it'.
  5. Keep notes. I'm personally inclined to look at people when I talk to them and when they talk to me, so I keep key points in my head during the meeting, but I do write them down later. These are helpful even months later, because a lot of the feedback is often predictions for the future.
  6. Assess before you act. One person may ask for another slide describing your technology while another thinks you have too many already. Sometimes feedback may be on something more strategic - your funding sources for example. Before you jump to changing your PowerPoint after each meeting, think about who said it and why and how it fits in with your vision. Don't make changes that don't sit well with you.
  7. Keep an open mind. We all get defensive, protective and just plain huffy if someone doesn't see our idea as great as think it is. Entirely understandable. But there's something to be said for seeking some level of detachment and assessing the input dispassionately. The people who're giving you the input are not dimwits (see a pattern here?), so taking their feedback seriously and thinking through it can't help but improve your idea. If nothing else, it will help you strengthen your story as you'll know how to respond to naysayers.
Is it possible to have too many opinions? If you're past the early stages of vetting and refining and you're feeling pretty solid about what you have, maybe you can dial down the opinion gathering to avoid TMO. But you probably won't ever turn it off - just move to another topic.